Lawyers Say Hillingdon Council’s Funding Cuts Consultation Was ‘Unlawful’

Lawyers representing the families of disabled adults forced to take legal action in the High Court to stop the closure of three day care centres they have relied on for up to 25 years say consultations by Hillingdon Council were ‘unlawful’ and the decision should be reversed.

The families are campaigning against the funding cuts which will not only affect themselves but other users of the Woodside Day Centre, the Phoenix Day Centre and the Parkview Day Centre, run by Hillingdon Council, which plans to replace them with a single day care centre at Queens Walk. None of the current users of the services are sure if they will get a place in the new centre.

Public law experts at Irwin Mitchell have now issued legal proceedings against Hillingdon Council as they seek a Judicial Review to stop the proposed closure of the day care centres. The families and their lawyers claim the council’s consultation on the cuts was unlawful and did not provide enough information to the public, families, local campaigners or the council’s Cabinet decision makers.

Alex Rook, a specialist in representing people fighting against cuts to public services at Irwin Mitchell, said: "On behalf of the families we are arguing that the decision by the council to cut funding for the three day care centres should be reversed. The plans to close these centres will have a massive impact on the attendees and their families. The proposals will halve the number of places from 140 to 70, in one centre to cover the whole of Hillingdon.

“None of the people who currently use the services know if they will be able to get a place at the proposed new site. Many of the disabled adults affected are extremely vulnerable people who demonstrate challenging behaviours when a change occurs in their routine, including self harming.

“Our clients consider that the consultations on the closures were inadequate in order to allow them to contribute in an informed way. The information provided to the centre users was missing several key details about what it meant for them and what alternative services might be available, and our clients remain in the dark about how the changes will actually affect them.

“There was strong opposition to these cuts from many local people who use the services but their views, we believe, were not correctly sought or captured. These are the very people who should have been helping to make the decision, and our clients are unanimously of the opinion that the consultation was little more than a tick box exercise.

“Ultimately, our clients believe that the councillors who had to vote on this issue were simply not given enough information about the impact the closures would have on the Hillingdon community, and that had they been, this decision would not have been taken.”

Irwin Mitchell is representing 47-year-old Paula Leonard who has Down’s syndrome. She has attended Woodside Day Care Centre for five days a week for the past 15 years. She needs help and supervision with all aspects of her daily life including in relation to her personal care.

Paula rarely speaks and communicates mainly through her own sign language and by showing people what she wants.  Because of this she needs stability in her care to achieve the best possible result.

Paula’s mother, June Leonard, said: “There are going to be fewer places now in the council’s plans and we still do not know if we will be offered a place or how Paula will get there. We’ve been using the Woodside centre for 15 years but I still don’t know if we will be able to go to use the new centre or not. The way the whole process was carried out was just shocking and we don’t know why or how these decisions were made because they clearly haven’t been listening to the people who use the centres.  The Council have stated that this is not about saving money, but we simply don’t believe that to be true.

 “We’ve tried to find a way to challenge the decision without legal action but have been left with no option but to instruct solicitors after Hillingdon Council said they would not review the decision themselves.”

Claudine Schopfer, whose daughter Melanie, aged 45, has also attended Woodside for the last 15 years, is equally distressed by the Council’s decision.  Melanie suffers from cerebral palsy and epilepsy, has significant care needs and requires 24 hour support in relation to her personal care. 

Claudine states: “I am very worried about how Melanie will react to losing friends, some of whom she has been with for the last 40 years. That is a long period of time to take into consideration, and I honestly think it will be devastating for her.”

 Another disabled adult has been using the Parkview Day Care Centre five days a week for 25 years and has built up a level of trust with the staff there. Her family say they are very worried about how she might react to the changes which, even if they did get a place, would mean long journeys to the new day centre and upheaval of more than two decades of developing the perfect care routine to suit her needs.

Her mother is in her 70s and relies heavily on the day care centre to provide care to her daughter during the week in order to provide her with respite care. Her daughter is unable to verbally communicate, is partially blind, doubly incontinent and needs 24 hour support to help with her personal care. 

Mark Goldring, Chief Executive of the learning disability charity Mencap, said: "We are hearing from people with a learning disability across the country who have experienced the closure of a day service without an appropriate alternative and do not feel that they have been involved, or even considered, in the decision.

“It is imperative that those affected are fully consulted on the changes that are happening. People with a learning disability and their families are worried about the future, and cuts such as this are leading to people losing vital services which allow them to socialise, build support networks and participate in their local community. The loss of these services can have severe consequences, with families often being left to pick up the pieces.”