Fox & Ors v Ahmad & Anor [2026] EWHC 2969 (Ch): Disputed Debts and the Creditor Duty

featured image

Considering the implications of the Judgment for Creditor Duty

19.11.2026

The High Court's decision in Fox & Ors v Ahmad & Anor [2026] EWHC 2969 (Ch) provides useful guidance on the application of the creditor duty established in BTI v Sequana and confirming how the principles in BTI v Sequana and subsequently Hunt v Singh operate in an investigation of transactions, confirming that insolvency remains central, but the court will also examine what the directors knew or ought to have known and the circumstances of each payment. In particular, it addresses the significance of a disputed liability when determining when the duty is engaged.

Background

The company owned and operated a shopping centre in Kidderminster and owed substantial unpaid business rates. Before entering liquidation, it made a series of payments involving its directors and associated parties, including the diversion of sale proceeds from the shopping centre and payments before and after presentation of the winding-up petition. The liquidators subsequently commenced a claim for misfeasance pursuant to section 212 of the Insolvency Act 1986. 

The Court found that substantially all the payments claimed were made in breach of the directors' duties, subject to two minor exceptions. Including interest and costs, the directors' liability exceeded £1.8 million.

When does the creditor duty arise?

The particularly useful aspect of the judgment concerns the directors' argument that the relevant debt was disputed.

The Court confirmed that insolvency is an objective state of affairs. Following Hunt v Singh, the judge held that engagement of the creditor duty does not automatically render subsequent transactions a breach. The court must consider the circumstances of each transaction individually to determine what the duty required and whether it was breached. 

A director's subjective belief that a liability is invalid does not, by itself, postpone engagement of the creditor duty. On the assumption that an element of knowledge is required, the relevant question was whether the directors knew or ought to have known that there was a real prospect of insolvency.

On the facts, the creditor duty was engaged by 8 July 2019, when substantial liabilities were being demanded and remained unchallenged, while the company's bank statements demonstrated that it had insufficient funds to meet them.

Practical implications 

The judgment highlights four useful points when investigating potential misfeasance claims:

  • Establish the financial timeline

Identify when significant liabilities were demanded, when they fell due and whether the company had the resources to meet them.

  • Scrutinise disputed liabilities

    Consider the contemporaneous basis for the dispute, any professional advice obtained and the realistic prospects of the challenge succeeding.

  • Analyse transactions individually

    Particular scrutiny should be given to payments to directors, relatives and connected entities, particularly where there is limited commercial justification or inadequate contemporaneous documentation.

  • Use the section 212 evidential burden 

    Once receipt of company money or property by a director is established, the evidential burden falls on the director to demonstrate that the payment or transfer was proper.

Key takeaway

The Judgment confirms that disputing a liability does not necessarily keep the creditor duty at bay. Contemporaneous evidence of the company's actual financial position, what the directors knew or ought to have known, and the circumstances surrounding each individual transaction will be central to assessing potential claims.

Hannah Lambert and Tom Paton represented the liquidators in Fox & Ors v Ahmad & Anor [2026] EWHC 2969 (Ch).

Key Contacts

Related Articles

  • Secured status, vesting orders and the limits of section 375 of the Insolvency Act 1986
    Expert Comment
    Secured status, vesting orders and the limits of section 375 of the Insolvency Act 1986
    In Fletcher & MacPherson v Desai the High Court considered whether section 375 of the Insolvency Act 1986 (“IA 1986”) could be used to revisit the consequences of a successful transaction at an undervalue claim and, in particular, whether it could operate to preserve or confer secured status on a creditor after bankruptcy.

Recognised for excellence. Chosen for care.

  • Legal 500 Top Tier Firm UK 202
  • alt tzt
  • Sunday Times Best Places to Work 2025
  • Kings Award Logo
  • ePrivateClient Top Law Firms 2025