
Immigration: Earned Settlement - The Character Assessment
Our immigration experts explain potential Earned Settlement changes
17.11.2026
Although not yet law, The Home Secretary’s response to the consultation on Earned Settlement has provided further clarity on how good character will potentially be assessed under the model when an individual applies for Indefinite Leave to Remain (‘ILR’), indicating that this will be a key determinant in the settlement process. However, these changes represent a significant uplift from the rules that are currently in place, and raise key questions regarding fairness that we will explore below.
Criminality
The Current Approach
Under Part Suitability of the current rules, an application must be refused where an applicant has received a custodial or suspended sentence of 12 months or more, they are a persistent offender with disregard for the law, or they have committed an offence that has caused serious harm.
An application may be refused where an applicant has received a custodial or suspended sentence of less than 12 months, a non-custodial sentence, or a recorded out-of-court disposal, where this is left to the discretion of the Secretary of State. This allows the Home Office to take into account a multitude of factors when considering whether to refuse an application – factors such as the time elapsed since the criminal act took place, any ties the applicant has to the UK, and the relevance of a first-time offence.
How ‘Earned Settlement’ Compares
The Home Secretary has announced that under the new Earned Settlement framework, any adult applicant with a criminal record in the UK will be refused settlement.
A criminal record is stated to cover the following:
- Custodial or suspended sentences
- Out-of-court disposals (e.g. cautions)
- Court-imposed fines
- Community sentences
- Detention and training orders
- Civil orders where there has been a conviction
As a result, the updated approach removes any element of discretion in the decision-making process when it comes to an individual’s criminal record, and there is no flexibility given to the Home Office to consider the broader details of each case before making a decision.
Although the existing framework is not flawless, its purpose is fairly straightforward. In the UK, individuals who commit serious crimes or repeatedly break the law are automatically barred from applying for permission, and any existing permissions will be revoked. For less severe offences, there is some flexibility allowing the Home Office to consider the broader details of each case before making a decision. This takes a proportionate approach, balancing national security with individual rights.
Effects of the ‘Earned Settlement’ Approach on Criminal Law and Immigration
The proposal by the Home Secretary to prevent ILR where one does not essentially have a ‘clean criminal record’ may therefore have wide implications on how criminal proceedings are approached.
If someone were to be convicted of an offence at court, whether that be in the magistrates or Crown Court or accept a caution, they would now be prevented from obtaining settlement in the UK under the new framework. This means the severity of the offence and/or sentence is no longer material to how an application for ILR is assessed by the Home Office and could therefore affect how criminal proceedings are negotiated – unless the individual is acquitted in court, they will very likely face a lifetime ban on applying for ILR in the UK.
It is important to note that this is a harsher standard than is applied in criminal law. Offences which are generally less serious or result in shorter custodial sentences can be considered ‘spent’ after a certain period of time (see government guidance here). Under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974, where a conviction is considered ‘spent’, it will not appear on a basic criminal records check after the relevant rehabilitation period has passed. For example, in certain circumstances, were someone to be sentenced to 12 months custody, or less, their conviction is considered spent 12 months after the end of that sentence. If someone has spent convictions, a basic criminal records check may show no record. Individuals aren't required to disclose spent convictions for most situations, for example job applications or insurance.
The Secretary of State’s approach therefore appears to be in direct conflict with the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974. Ultimately the court’s view in criminal proceedings is that the sentence should serve as punishment but the punishment, unless in the most serious circumstances, should not be indefinite. By barring these individuals from ever applying for ILR, they are in effect being further punished for their conviction.
Such rigidity could be criticised for failing to distinguish between minor offences and more serious criminal behaviour, and for not taking into account rehabilitation, the passage of time, or the circumstances surrounding the offence. This approach therefore overlooks the principles of fairness and rehabilitation recognised by the wider justice system, placing a disproportionate burden on foreign offenders to secure a clean record compared with those already entitled to live permanently in the UK.
What else does ‘Earned Settlement’ Change?
In addition to the changes to the criminality requirement, the new Earned Settlement framework has also made changes on how the Home Office will consider other areas when assessing good character.
Government debt requirement
Part Suitability currently provides that an application may be refused where an applicant has failed to pay charges under relevant NHS regulations on charges to overseas visitors that total at least £500, or where an applicant has failed to pay litigation costs awarded to the Home Office.
The Earned Settlement framework has expanded this further, so that applicants will be required to have no outstanding government debt before they can settle, which will include the following:
- NHS debt
- Tax debt, including unpaid tax
- National Insurance contributions
- Litigation debt owed to the Home Office
Refugees who have claimed asylum in the UK and have received asylum support will additionally be required to pay those costs, either by repaying the amount owed in full or demonstrating sustained compliance with an agreed repayment plan.
It is difficult to see how this new approach could be considered fair and proportionate when compared to the existing rules which allow for some discretion. Taking a look at wider guidance, the ‘Good Character’ requirement for British citizenship applications, does not require the refusal of an application on a mandatory basis where a person has outstanding debt, and instead looks at their financial soundness in totality to provide an overall assessment of good character on the balance of probabilities. Comparing this to the Earned Settlement framework, it would be therefore more difficult to apply for Indefinite Leave to Remain than it would be to apply for British citizenship.
Immigration breaches
Part Suitability currently provides that a breach of immigration laws by an individual over the age of 18 may lead to the refusal of an application where an application has been made outside a mandatory refusal period, which can include:
- Overstaying your permission
- Breaching a condition attached to your permission
- Illegal entry
- The use of deception in relation to a previous application
- Acting to frustrate immigration controls
Where current rules allow the Home Office to exercise discretion and consider wider circumstances, the Earned Settlement position is much harsher. The new framework provides that specified immigration breaches committed as an adult will automatically place an applicant on a 20-year pathway to settlement, regardless of their income or other positive contributions that could otherwise reduce their qualifying period under the new framework.
It is unclear how this can be framed as proportionate, as no qualifiers have been provided at this stage. For example, those who potentially overstay their permission for a few weeks as they wait for their sponsor to issue their Certificate of Sponsorship will potentially see their qualifying period for settlement at least double with no possible mitigation, regardless of their overall salary or wider circumstances. An individual in this situation appears to be met with the same punishment in terms of the increase to their qualifying period as an individual who participated in immigration related crime, for example.
The Home Office have stated that this approach reflects their view that settlement should recognise sustained compliance as well as contribution, but an individual who has had an incredibly minor breach of the immigration laws weighed against an otherwise spotless immigration history will be punished regardless. In practice, immigration breaches often have a significant amount of context behind them that may either explain why they occurred, or provide mitigation, but the new proposals do not allow for these arguments to be heard.
Conclusion
In summary, the Earned Settlement framework on character risks imposing an unduly harsh regime on foreign nationals looking to settle in the UK. Previous mistakes cannot be rehabilitated, and applicants are essentially required to have a spotless record across the areas of crime, debt and immigration law.
By removing the existing discretionary power under the Immigration Rules which allows the Home Office to consider an individual’s circumstances and weigh up whether a refusal would be proportionate, the Earned Settlement proposals will look to implement a draconian system where foreign nationals may effectively be locked out of the ability to settle permanently no matter the circumstance.
Ultimately, a more balanced system is needed; one that protects public interests, but also recognises the importance of second chances, individual circumstances, and proportionality in decision-making.
Key Contacts
Related Articles
Expert CommentExpansion of Right to Work Checks – One Month Before the Changes: What Businesses Need to Know Before 1 October 2026The UK Government is set to introduce one of the most significant changes to illegal working compliance since the civil penalty regime was first introduced in February 2008. From 1 October 2026, Section 48 of the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025 will substantially expand the scope of the Right to Work Scheme beyond traditional employment relationships and into a range of modern working arrangements.
Expert CommentKey Updates in the Statement of Changes to the Immigration Rules – 14 October 2025The Home Office has issued a fresh update to the UK Immigration Rules (HC 1333) on 14 October 2025 in a new iteration of its ‘White Paper’ implementations. In this article, we’ll break down some of the main changes you need to know about—changes that are likely to affect both individuals and businesses navigating the UK’s immigration system. Notably, these updates could have a real impact on a lot of people looking to live, work, or study in the UK.English Language Requirement AmendmentsGraduate Route Duration ReducedHigh Potential Individual Route ChangesIncreased Priority Fees for Sponsor Licence ApplicationsOther Notable Changes
Expert CommentIndefinite Leave under threat: Reform UK’s radical immigration proposalsSince its inception, the Reform UK political party, led by Nigel Farage, has not been discrete about their nationalism and anti-immigration policies, beginning with Nigel’s ‘Brexit’ campaign in 2016. His latest focus is on what he terms the “Boriswave” - the influx of individuals entering the UK under post-Brexit immigration rules introduced by Boris Johnson’s government.






