Elder abuse: A 'serious issue that requires immediate attention and action' says legal expert

Senior woman with black eye is victim of domestic violence

Reading about Nicola Hughes’ experience with her mother’s care at Barrogil House in Fife was both heartbreaking and eye-opening.

17.03.2025

As a legal professional who specialises in abuse cases, I found this case particularly disturbing. It highlighted the severe issues that can arise in care homes and the desperate measures families sometimes have to take to ensure their loved ones are safe.

An emotional burden on loved ones

The emotional toll on families dealing with elder abuse is immense. Watching a loved one suffer and feeling powerless to help is incredibly distressing. Nicola’s story underscores the importance of vigilance and advocacy in protecting vulnerable elderly individuals. 

It also highlights the emotional burden on families who must navigate these challenges while trying to ensure their loved ones receive the care they deserve.

Many forms of elder abuse

Elder abuse is a pervasive issue that extends far beyond individual cases. It can occur in various settings, including private homes, nursing homes, and assisted living facilities. 

Abuse can take many forms, such as physical, emotional, financial, and neglect. Each type of abuse has devastating effects on the well-being and dignity of elderly individuals.

What does the data show?

Statistics show that between 50,000 and 90,000 older people living in their own homes in Scotland may suffer at least one form of abuse. Psychological abuse is the most common, affecting 36% of victims, followed by physical abuse (25%), financial abuse (20%), institutional abuse (12%), neglect (5%), and sexual abuse (2%). Additionally, a 2020 poll by Hourglass revealed that there were more than 225,000 older victims of abuse in Scotland.

In my role as a legal expert, it's clear to me that the need for rigorous standards and oversight in care homes is crucial. Families should not have to resort to covert measures to ensure their loved ones are treated with respect and compassion. It's crucial for care homes to maintain high standards and for regulatory bodies to enforce these standards rigorously.

A reminder of the importance of advocacy

Elder abuse in Scotland, as illustrated by Nicola’s case, is a serious issue that requires immediate attention and action. Her determination to improve conditions at the care home is a testament to her love for her mother and her commitment to ensuring a safe and dignified environment for all residents. Her story serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of advocacy.

Find out more about Irwin Mitchell's expertise in supporting survivors of abuse at our dedicated abuse and criminal injuries section.

Key Contacts

Related Articles

  • 10 years of the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry (SCAI) - the pros, the cons and what should happen next?
    Expert Comment
    10 years of the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry (SCAI) - the pros, the cons and what should happen next?
    The Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry (SCAI) launched in 2015 to uncover the truth about systemic abuse in care settings between 1930 to 2014.
  • Abuse expert's concerns over accounts of mistreatment at Skye House
    Expert Comment
    Abuse expert's concerns over accounts of mistreatment at Skye House
    As a legal expert specialising in abuse cases, I'm deeply troubled by the accounts of mistreatment at Skye House, Scotland's largest children's psychiatric hospital.
  • Expert Comment
    Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry into Queen Victoria School: Legal expert reflects on findings
    Reflecting on the findings of the child abuse inquiry specific to Queen Victoria School (QVS), it's clear that the investigation has revealed a deeply concerning history of systemic abuse that spanned decades.