GMC Finds That Breast Surgeon Is Fit To Practise
Breast surgeon cleared by General Medical Council
04/12/2008
The General Medical Council (GMC) in Manchester has found that Staffordshire breast surgeon, Mr Brian Gwynn’s fitness to practise was not impaired, despite him historically committing a series of operating blunders, leaving his patients with horrific wounds and permanent scars. The GMC did find, however, that there were serious breaches of Mr Gwynn's duties as a medical practitioner and serious breaches of the principles of good medical practice which amounted to misconduct in three separate cases.
The hearing, which originally opened in October 2007 considered charges of misconduct and deficient professional performance against Mr Gwynn. Initially, the GMC was asked to consider the evidence of 11 complainants but following a Judicial Review, the panel was ordered to discount the evidence of five former patients due to time limitations.
Mr Gwynn was first ordered to appear before the GMC’s Interim Orders Panel (IOP), in November 2005 and at that time an 18-month ban was imposed preventing him from carrying out breast surgery in any NHS or private practise. This ban has been reviewed and reinstated every six months, preventing Mr Gwynn from returning to breast surgery. This latest GMC hearing will decide whether to permanently bar him from carrying out any future breast surgery.
Mr Gwynn’s errors first came to light in March 2003 when Tracy Todd, a 39 year-old supermarket assistant and mother of three from Cannock, Staffordshire, sued the surgeon after her breast reduction operation in September 2002 left her with ‘horrific’ wounds, putting her health at risk with infections, and leaving her with misshapen breasts of different sizes. Mrs Todd had been left so badly injured that she was referred to an NHS plastic surgeon for corrective surgery. She required further surgery in November 2002 and again in March 2003.
Mr Gwynn was reported to the GMC by Irwin Mitchell solicitors who have brought a number of separate cases for negligence against the surgeon who operated both privately at Rowley Hall Hospital in Stafford and also with the NHS at Stafford General Hospital.
Ally Taft, solicitor at the Midlands’ offices of Irwin Mitchell, who represents Tracey Todd, says: “As a direct result of publicity surrounding Tracy’s case, I was contacted by a further 17 women, all of whom had suffered very poor outcomes following operations performed by Mr Gwynn. I have been instructed to pursue cases for negligence for 12 of the women, five of which have already successfully settled out of court.
"As a clinical negligence solicitor I am accustomed to seeing many cases in which claims arise due to one-off errors of judgement or system failures not entirely of an individual clinician’s making. I rarely feel the need to involve the GMC in any of my cases. However, with these particular cases such was the extent of my clients’ injuries - and my concern that these women were only the tip of the iceberg - that I took the decision to report Mr Gwynn’s practices to the GMC’s Fitness to Practice Directorate.
"Following the initial six-week hearing in 2005, followed by a second three-week hearing earlier this year we hoped that this final four-week hearing would bring the matter to a conclusion and offer closure for all those affected. However, my clients are surprised and disappointed by the decision that Mr Gwynn remains fit to practice despite the misconduct and serious breaches identified."
The GMC hearing has now been adjourned again, until 27 February 2009, when the panel will reach a decision on whether any sanction should be made, such as warning on Mr Gwynn’s registration.